360 Talent Solutions

Hire the Right Sales Professionals with The Predictive Index

Reading Time: 7 minutes

Hiring the right sales professionals is one of the most challenging and impactful tasks any organisation faces. A bad hire in sales isn’t just a mistake, it’s costly in ways that ripple across the entire business. Wasted time, lost revenue, damaged team morale, and strained customer relationships are just the beginning. Sales teams are the driving force behind growth, so the pressure to get hiring right is immense. Research shows that a third of new hires start looking for another job within six months, while turnover rates in sales roles can reach as high as 30%. The impact of these statistics goes beyond budgets and recruitment pipelines. The wrong hire disrupts workflows, creates team imbalances, and slows momentum, making it harder to reach revenue goals. Many organisations rely on traditional hiring methods such as CV reviews, interviews, and gut instinct, but these tools often fall short. They fail to answer critical questions: Does this candidate possess the intrinsic traits needed for sales success in your unique environment? Will they adapt and thrive in your team? Without a science-based approach, hiring can feel like an expensive gamble.

Table of Contents

Why Traditional Hiring Falls Short

Traditional hiring methods focus heavily on skills and experience, which, while important, are only part of the equation. Sales success hinges on behavioural traits like resilience, adaptability, and drive—qualities that are difficult to measure through a CV or interview. Skills can be taught, but innate traits like risk tolerance, urgency, and assertiveness are deeply ingrained and critical for long-term success. Salespeople are natural persuaders and often excel in interviews. However, a candidate who dazzles in the interview room may falter when faced with the realities of a challenging sales environment. Misalignments between a candidate’s behavioural tendencies and the demands of the role can lead to disengagement, burnout, and turnover, all of which impact revenue and morale. Without a robust, data-driven process, many organisations settle for candidates who are “good enough” rather than building high-performing teams capable of delivering consistent results.

A professonal asking interview questions in an office

The Predictive Index: A Smarter Approach

The Predictive Index (PI) transforms hiring by providing a data-driven, scientifically validated framework to identify candidates who are behaviourally aligned with the demands of a sales role. Unlike traditional methods that rely on surface-level metrics or subjective judgments, PI delves deeper to uncover the behavioural traits that predict long-term success. Backed by over 65 years of behavioural science, PI eliminates guesswork and empowers organisations to make confident, informed hiring decisions. It’s not just a tool but a comprehensive strategy for hiring, onboarding, and team development. By using PI, companies build sales teams that are not only skilled but behaviourally equipped to drive revenue, foster collaboration, and reduce costly turnover.

How The Predictive Index Works

Building a high-performing sales team requires more than impressive CVs or charisma; it demands a science-backed process that ensures every hire aligns with the unique needs of the organisation. PI offers a three-step process to make hiring smarter and more effective:

1.      The first step is Job Targeting, where PI helps define the ideal profile for the role. This involves identifying the behavioural and cognitive traits that will set a candidate up for success. Stakeholders, including sales leaders and hiring managers, contribute to creating the Job Target, ensuring it reflects the role’s true demands. For instance, a fast-paced role may require high dominance and low patience, while a relationship-focused sales position might demand high extroversion and moderate formality. These benchmarks, informed by decades of research, ensure clarity and alignment between organisational goals and the hiring process.

2. The next step is Candidate Assessment, where PI’s Behavioural and Cognitive Assessments come into play. The Behavioural Assessment measures drives like dominance, extroversion, patience, and formality, which combine to form a Reference Profile. For example, a Maverick might thrive in a competitive sales environment, while a Collaborator could excel in long-term account management. The Cognitive Assessment evaluates learning agility, critical for technical or consultative sales roles. Together, these tools provide a complete picture of each candidate’s potential, going beyond what traditional methods can uncover.

 

3.  Finally, PI’s software matches candidates to the Job Target, scoring them on a scale from one to ten. This ensures only the best-aligned candidates progress, reducing bias, saving time, and improving hiring outcomes.

An example of the Behavioral Assessment by Predictive Index

Real-World Success with The Predictive Index

The Predictive Index has transformed hiring processes across industries, delivering measurable results:

  • A global manufacturing company struggling with high turnover among their outside sales reps is a prime example. Despite investing heavily in training, only a small fraction of their team consistently met sales targets. By implementing PI, they redefined their hiring process to focus on traits like high dominance and urgency. The results were remarkable: sales increased by 300%, and turnover dropped by 25%.
  • Another success story comes from a tech start-up scaling its sales development team. Facing high SDR burnout due to a demanding cold-calling environment, the company used PI to identify candidates with resilience and urgency. The results included a doubling of their pipeline and a reduction in turnover from 40% to 15%.

You May Also Be Interested In

Explore the transformative impact of The Predictive Index Behavioral Assessment™ in enhancing hiring accuracy, team dynamics, and leadership effectiveness. Learn how this tool offers deep insights into workplace behaviors, driving smarter decisions and fostering a more productive and harmonious work environment

Beyond Hiring: Using PI for Sales Team Development

The Predictive Index goes beyond hiring, becoming a tool for ongoing team development and performance optimisation. It helps managers tailor their approach based on individual behavioural insights. For instance, a high-dominance salesperson may excel with autonomy, while a high-extroversion team member might thrive in collaborative settings. By aligning coaching and incentives with these traits, managers can boost engagement and performance. PI also supports team dynamics by identifying behavioural gaps and redundancies. A team with too many hunters may struggle with account management, while one with too many farmers might lack new business development. PI ensures the right balance, fostering collaboration and reducing conflict. Over time, organisations that leverage PI see improved cross-functional collaboration and a culture of data-driven decision-making, creating a foundation for long-term success.

4 team members working together on a project

How to Get Started with The Predictive Index

Implementing PI into your hiring process is straightforward. First, define the role with precision, using PI’s Job Targeting tool to map out the behavioural and cognitive traits needed for success. Next, integrate PI assessments early in the process. Use the Behavioural Assessment to understand workplace drives and the Cognitive Assessment for roles requiring learning agility. Combine these insights with structured interviews and role-specific evaluations to ensure a holistic view of each candidate. Once you’ve hired the right person, use PI insights to tailor onboarding and accelerate integration into the team. Finally, continuously evaluate and refine your hiring benchmarks, using PI analytics to adapt to changing organisational needs.

Why Companies Trust The Predictive Index

Over 6,000 organisations worldwide rely on The Predictive Index to optimise hiring and team-building processes. PI is grounded in science, with over 450 validity studies proving its accuracy. Its ease of use, compliance with legal standards, and proven ROI make it a trusted partner for businesses of all sizes. Companies like Nissan, which saw a 20% sales increase using PI, illustrate its transformative impact. By fostering collaboration, reducing turnover, and aligning talent strategies with business goals, PI delivers lasting value.

CLAIM YOUR FREE COPY
Top Five Hiring Challenges For 2024

Final Thoughts

Hiring the right sales professionals is about more than filling roles, it’s about building a foundation for success. The Predictive Index provides the tools and insights to hire with confidence, creating high-performing teams that drive revenue and growth. Ready to transform your hiring process? Contact us today and take the first step toward building your dream sales team.

In Partnership With Humanostics

360 Talent Solutions Ltd is an Associate Partner of Humanostics® , a PI Certified Partner authorised to use the science, assessment software, and curriculum of management workshops of The Predictive Index.

In partnership with Humanostics, we provide companies in the UK and across Europe access to the assessment tools provided by The Predictive Index.

Take the 6-minute PI Behavioral Assessment™ today.  Once you have completed the 6-minute assessment, I will send you a Full Behavioral Report by Predictive Index.

How Can We Help

From supporting the growth of leading pharma companies over the past 10 years, I have learnt that when it comes to predicting future performance, technology is key:

  • Education, years of experience, and references all have low predictive value. Yet, we rely on these for screening early in the recruitment process.
  • Cognitive and Behavioural Assessments, have much higher predictive value, and when combined with interviews, provide the most effective method for predicting future performance.

For me, hiring without the use of psychometric assessments is like trying to put together a jigsaw puzzle with pieces missing … and no picture on the box. It’s not fun, it takes longer, and when you are almost finished, you realise you have pieces missing.

Take the assessment today and start measuring more to improve your recruitment.

If you are interested in learning more or are ready to incorporate behavioral data into your recruitment process, please contact me today, I will be happy to help.

Let’s get started!

Dave Crumby

Founder at 360 Talent Solutions

Certified Predictive Index Practitioner 

Potrait of Dave Crumby in a suite
Our Latest News & Insights
The logo for STOH
The Swiss Talent Optimisation Hub

Join The Swiss Talent Optimisation Hub (STOH) to connect with HR professionals dedicated to leveraging Predictive Index tools and behavioural science to overcome unique challenges faced by Swiss businesses and drive organisational success.

Read More